Accord and satisfaction

Accord and satisfaction

Accord and satisfaction bezeichnet im englischen Vertragsrecht einen Vertragstyp, bei dem der Schuldner durch einen neuen Vertrag eine Einrede gegen den alten Vertrag erwirbt. Der Schuldner "kauft" sich dabei von seiner Verpflichtung frei, dies geschieht jedoch nicht in Erfüllung der ursprünglichen Verpflichtung. Es entsteht vielmehr ein neuer Vertrag mit den Voraussetzungen Antrag (offer), Annahme (acceptance) und consideration, den der Schuldner dem Gläubiger des ursprünglichen Vertrages als defence (Einrede) entgegenhalten kann. Die klassische Definition von accord and satisfaction stammt von Scrutton LJ in British Russion Gazette, Ltd. v Associated Newspapers, Ltd. [1933]:

“Accord and satisfaction ist the purchase of a release from an obligation, whether arisiing under contract or tort, by means of any valuable consideration, not being the actual performance of the obligation itself. The accord is the agreement by which the obligation is discharged. The satisfaction is the consideration which makes the agreement operative. ”

Für die satisfaction gelten die allgemeinen Anforderungen an consideration. Insbesondere liegt keine consideration vor, wenn die ursprüngliche Schuld lediglich verringert wird. In diesem Falle muss ein zusätzlicher Nachteil für den Schuldner oder Vorteil für den Gläubiger vom Schuldner dem Gläubiger zukommen (vgl. Pinnel’s Case (1608), Foakes v Beer (1884)). Liegt keine wirksame consideration vor oder sind sonstige Wirksamkeitsvoraussetzungen eines Vertrages nicht erfüllt, kann der Gläubiger ungehindert aus dem ursprünglichen Vertrag klagen.

Beispiel: A beauftragt B mit einem Hausbau für 1.000.000 £ zahlt hierfür 100.000 £ an. Entsprechend dem Baufortschritt sollen jeweils weitere Raten gezahlt werden. Bei Fertigstellung weigert sich A die letzte Rate von 100.000 £ zu zahlen, da Baumängel vorlägen. A und B einigen sich darauf (accord), dass B nur noch 50.000 £ erhalten soll. Im Gegenzug will A auf seine Mängelrechte verzichten (satisfaction).

Wikimedia Foundation.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Schlagen Sie auch in anderen Wörterbüchern nach:

  • accord and satisfaction — n. A means of ending a dispute by forming an agreement (the accord) that one party will pay the other some consideration (the satisfaction, often less than the amount originally agreed to) and that this will discharge any remaining obligation.… …   Law dictionary

  • Accord and satisfaction — In contract law, accord and satisfaction is the purchase of the release from a debt obligation. The payment is typically less than what is owed and is not paid by the actual performance of the original obligation. The accord is the agreement to… …   Wikipedia

  • accord and satisfaction — A method of discharging a claim whereby the parties agree to give and accept something in settlement of the claim and perform the agreement, the accord being the agreement and the satisfaction its execution or performance, and it is a new… …   Black's law dictionary

  • accord and satisfaction — A method of discharging a claim whereby the parties agree to give and accept something in settlement of the claim and perform the agreement, the accord being the agreement and the satisfaction its execution or performance, and it is a new… …   Black's law dictionary

  • Accord And Satisfaction — A legal contract whereby two parties agree to discharge a tort claim, contract or other liability for an amount or based on terms that differ from the original amount of the contract or claim. Accord and satisfaction is also used to settle legal… …   Investment dictionary

  • accord and satisfaction — A device enabling one party to a contract to avoid an obligation that arises under the contract, provided that the other party agrees. The accord is the agreement by which the contractual obligation is discharged and the satisfaction is the… …   Accounting dictionary

  • accord and satisfaction — A device enabling one party to a contract to avoid an obligation that arises under the contract, provided that the other party agrees. The accord is the agreement by which the contractual obligation is discharged and the satisfaction is the… …   Big dictionary of business and management

  • accord and satisfaction — noun the settlement of a debt by paying less than the amount demanded in exchange for extinguishing the debt • Hypernyms: ↑settlement * * * accord and satisfaction (commerce) The process by which a party agrees to release the other party from… …   Useful english dictionary

  • accord and satisfaction —    An agreement to accept less than is legally due in order to conclude a dispute. The new agreement (i.e., the accord) and the payment (i.e., the satisfaction, when made) replace the original obligation.    See novation …   Business law dictionary

  • accord and satisfaction — An executed agreement of accord. 1 Am J2d Accord § 1. In order to be a satisfaction there must be an accord or agreement to accept in extinction of the obligation something different from or less than that which the creditor is claiming or is… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”